IPCC Report Delay Threatens Global Climate Cooperation, Warns Top Scientist
Johan Rockström, director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, has warned that attempts by certain nations to delay the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s next comprehensive assessment threaten global cooperation on tackling the climate crisis. The dispute centers on accusations of bias in scientific representation, with some countries seeking to postpone the report until after the critical global stocktake.
Johan Rockström, the director of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, has issued a stark warning that attempts to delay the publication of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change’s (IPCC) next comprehensive assessment threaten to undermine global cooperation on the climate crisis. Rockström argued that climate science is foundational to the Paris Agreement and that slowing down scientific work puts international progress at risk.
The dispute centers on the IPCC’s seventh assessment report, known as AR7, which is currently under development. While the panel aims to complete the three-part report by 2028, a coalition of countries, including Russia, India, and the Arab group of nations led by Saudi Arabia, is pushing to delay its publication until 2029. Their primary objection is that the current process disadvantages developing countries and is underpinned by racist assumptions that favor the global north.
Rockström rejected these characterizations, describing the IPCC as an objective, evidence-based body that serves as the reliable foundation for policymaking. "The IPCC is the summary of everything done voluntarily by scientists from the entire world, global south and global north, that collectively carries out a synthesis [of established research]," Rockström said. He emphasized that the report’s pathways to the future represent different socioeconomic realities based on peer-reviewed science, not political bias.
"We have to defend that objective science," Rockström told reporters at Cop31 in Turkey. "We should not use science as the arena to fight for justice or human rights or even democracy. That’s not the role of science."
The timing of the report is critical because it will inform the upcoming global stocktake under the Paris Agreement, scheduled for the autumn of 2028 at Cop33. This mechanism is designed to assess progress toward the core goal of limiting global temperature rise to 1.5C above pre-industrial levels. Current UN data indicates the world is on track for a 2.8C rise, a scenario previous IPCC reports have linked to severe and potentially irreversible consequences, including ice cap melting, sea-level rise, coral bleaching, and extreme weather events.
Critics of the current process argue that the IPCC’s mitigation scenarios are biased against the interests of the global south. Lidy Nacpil, coordinator of the Asian Peoples’ Movement on Debt and Development, stated that one key assumption in the reports is that emissions cuts should be made where they are most cost-efficient. "And where is it cheap to do mitigation? In the global south," she said. She argued that changing these assumptions would produce different scenarios and accused some nations of using their economic and political power to deflect responsibility.
Nacpil also addressed the criticism directed at Saudi Arabia, noting that singling out the country was "very racist." She questioned who started the fossil fuel industries in the region and who has benefited from them for decades. "This is not us taking sides," she said. "This is us saying: ‘But the pot is calling the kettle black.’"
Despite these objections, many developing nations, including small island states and least developed countries, have called for the IPCC report to be completed without delay. Raju Pandit Chhetri, a negotiator from Nepal, described the accusation of racism as "a political line." He highlighted the immediate impacts of climate change in his home country, citing the loss of lives and billions in property damage. "What we need to do in this process is really respect the science," he said. "There are countries who think that making stronger science will put pressure on them to [cut emissions]."
The IPCC has defended its diversity efforts, stating that 51% of the 664 appointed authors for the AR7 drafts come from developing countries and economies in transition, an increase of nearly half compared to the last report in 2021. Each chapter includes at least one scientist from a developing country. A spokesperson said the panel is committed to promoting diversity, inclusion, integrity, and professionalism.
Rockström noted that even if AR7 is delayed, the evidence from the previous assessment (AR6) is sufficient to show that current emissions pledges are inadequate. "We have all the evidence we need," he said. "Even if you based your updates only on AR6, we would still be making enormous progress."
However, experts fear that a delay could be used by some nations to derail the global stocktake itself. One expert involved in the process described the situation as "throwing more sand in the gears." The conflict is intensifying as the IPCC prepares to meet to decide its budget. While the panel has reserves, a failure to agree on a budget would make it unlikely that reports could be produced before the stocktake.
Although IPCC issues are technically resolved within the body and not at Cop conferences, some form of compromise may be possible given the ongoing negotiations in Turkey. Jim Skea, the chair of the IPCC, extended his attendance at Cop31 to hold further talks on the issue. The first draft of the cover decision from Cop31 recognizes the central role of the best available science and the IPCC, as well as the value of participation from indigenous peoples, people of African descent, and developing countries.
The outcome of these negotiations will determine whether the scientific community can provide timely data to guide global climate policy or if political disputes will create a gap in the evidence base at a critical juncture for international cooperation.
T.Murray--SMC